Mystery & Whodunit Generator for Fantasy Adventures

Roll a solvable mystery for your table: the crime, four suspects with motives and alibis, four clues that point to the culprit, two red herrings, and how the guilty party reacts when caught. Hide the GM notes to show the suspect list to your players.

Crime
Setting

Saved mysteries kept on this device

Save a mystery to come back to it later.

Running a mystery the players can solve

Mysteries fall apart when the players miss the one clue that matters. This generator gives you four separate clues that each point to the culprit: something left at the scene, a trace found on the culprit, a witness who noticed a telling detail, and a fact that breaks the culprit’s alibi. The players only need to find two of them. The two red herrings point at innocent suspects, but each leads to a smaller secret, so following them is still rewarding.

Notice that the witness describes what they saw, not who. Match the detail to a suspect’s look and the players can work it out themselves. Use Hide GM notes to show or print the suspect list without motives, secrets or the solution. All text is original to Tavern & Torch and free to use in your games.

Related: flesh out a suspect with the NPC generator, place the crime in a generated town or tavern, print a wanted poster with the handout maker, and steer the interrogations with the social interaction rules.

Frequently asked questions

How do I make sure my players can solve the mystery?

Each mystery has four separate clues that point to the culprit: a physical clue at the scene, a trace found on the culprit, a witness detail, and a fact that breaks their alibi. The players only need two, so missing one never stalls the game.

What are the red herrings for?

They point at two innocent suspects, but each one leads to that suspect’s own smaller secret, such as a debt or a forbidden romance. Following them still uncovers something interesting, and clears the suspect.

Can I show the suspect list to my players?

Yes. Tick “Hide GM notes” to hide motives, secrets, clues and the solution, then show or print the page, or use “Copy suspect list” to copy only what the players should see.